The Best Meatless Holiday Mains and Vegetarian Thanksgiving Recipes (2024)

Holiday meals tend to follow a specific formula that’s a lot less flexible than ordinary dinner parties.

The Best Meatless Holiday Mains and Vegetarian Thanksgiving Recipes (1)

There are the canapes, of course, followed by a more formal buffet. And while the main event is often notable for a bevy of festive autumnal sides, usually they function in supporting roles to the centerpiece: an impressively carved animal.

Though I myself am usually more interested in the sides (hello, carbs) than the main course, as a vegetarian, these holiday meals can sometimes feel a little incomplete.

At a casual dinner party, it wouldn’t be at all unusual to have a veggie pasta or pot of carrot soup as the piece de resistance. But, at holiday meals we’re used to this formula of protein at the center, with all the accoutrements filling the other corners of the plate.

To help combat this culinary conundrum, I’ve put together a list of the best plant-based holiday main courses that you can make the centerpiece of your table this Thanksgiving, Christmakkah and beyond.

If you’re interested in eating less meat, you might also care to partake in some more eco-friendly wine, which is why I’ve also offered up some fabulous organic wines from Italy for the occasion.

These bottles are perfect for any holiday table (even those who follow a more traditional menu), but are particularly tasty withthe below vegetarian entrees. Read on for the meat-free main courses and wines to match!

With health and hedonism,

Phoebe

THE BEST MAIN COURSE VEGETARIAN THANKSGIVING RECIPES

The Best Meatless Holiday Mains and Vegetarian Thanksgiving Recipes (2)

Vegetarian Cassoulet with Mushrooms and Chard This classic French dish has all the important food groups going for it—protein, carbs, veggies—without any of the meat. Since it’s rather labor intensive, the traditional version is a great option for a homey New Year’s Eve main course that presents beautifully served in one casserole. Since it looks like a pile of goodness on the plate anyway, this veggie version with chardand mushrooms is no different, other than being even more colorful and appealing.

The Best Meatless Holiday Mains and Vegetarian Thanksgiving Recipes (3)

Vegetarian Harissa Mushroom Bolognese with Creamy Coconut Polenta This composed plate is a more star worthy dinner party option than a humble pasta. For an over the top presentation, pour the polenta onto a slate or wooden board in front of your guests and spoon the mushroom bolognese sauce on top! They do this at a fabulous restaurant, Sauce, near me.

The Best Meatless Holiday Mains and Vegetarian Thanksgiving Recipes (4)

Pumpkin Mac and Cheese with Kale Ok, Mac and cheese might be on the more casual side, but nothing could feel more like a complete filling meal. With kale and pumpkin, it gets major plant points for seasonal colors!

The Best Meatless Holiday Mains and Vegetarian Thanksgiving Recipes (5)

Healthy Stuffed Mushrooms with Creamed Kale Though this recipe was originally pioneered as an appetizer with small creminis, you could easily craft a beautiful main course for Thanksgiving using a larger portobello. This is also a great strategy for a bread based stuffing!

The Best Meatless Holiday Mains and Vegetarian Thanksgiving Recipes (6)

Vegetarian Shepherd’s Pie with Lentils and Mushrooms While the Irish casserole leaves a little to be desired in terms of elegance, this shepherd’s pie becomes a stunning main course if you bake and serve it in individual ramekins or cocottes. This vegetarian version with lentils is perfectly savory and delicious.

The Best Meatless Holiday Mains and Vegetarian Thanksgiving Recipes (7)

Root Vegetable Tagine with Kale Thinking a little bit outside the usual box, this Moroccan stew is a beautiful way to serve up the best of the season’s vegetables with tons of savory warming spices. Serve it in a large skillet alongside couscous or quinoa and plenty of bread for soaking.

Herb Crusted Tofu with sh*take Mushroom Gravy Perhaps the most traditional main course replacement for Thanksgiving Turkey, this beautiful tofu dish from Lily Diamond has everything you would want in a centerpiece: crunch, creaminess and exceptionally umami gravy.

THE BEST ORGANIC WINES FOR YOUR HOLIDAY TABLE

Zucchi Lambrusco di Sorbara Lambrusco, the effervescent “frizzante” from Emilia-Romagna, is the perfect party drink to elevate a celebration, while complementing some of the sweeter autumn fare on your plate. The region best known for production of the Sorbara clone of the Lambrusco grape is located to the north of Modena, and its version of this sparkling elixir is the lightest-hued of the bunch. This bottle features fresh raspberries and violets, which pairs perfectly with the sweet and savory notes of myPumpkin Mac and Cheese with Kaleand other root vegetable-focused dishes.

Ceretto Barbaresco Made from 100% Nebbiolo grapes grown in the Barbaresco region, this is a classic wine with perfect balance between structure and elegance, exactly what you want on your holiday table. It’s a medium-bodied, ruby-red wine with an aroma of dried cherries and rose petals, plus undertones of vanilla and spices. It pairs nicely with most meats, but can stand up equally well to savory, umami-rich, vegetarian dishes like myVegetarian Shepherd’s Pie with Lentils and Mushrooms, or theVegetarian Cassoulet.

2016 Toscana Rosso Monteleccio, Sesti Imported by one of my favorite companies, Kermit Lynch, this beautiful Toscana Rossois vibrant and structured, with an inherent energy and poise. This wine is made by a Brunello di Montalcino producer from grapes that do not go into the Brunello or Rosso di Montalcino. However, it is still 100% Sangiovese. This is an historic producer in a hugely important growing area. This wine is a great way to experience this particular territory without breaking the bank.It’s an incrediblyelegant wine, and an especially remarkable one given the price point. Produced in Tuscany, it pairs well with rustic, homey dishes, which usually make an appearance on the holiday table in the form of sides. For a vegetarian main course, it would go especially with theHerb Crusted Tofu with sh*take Mushroom Gravy.

This post is brought to you in partnership withwines of Italy. Make sure to check out their video to learn moreabout the magic of Italian wines!

The Best Meatless Holiday Mains and Vegetarian Thanksgiving Recipes (8)

The Best Meatless Holiday Mains and Vegetarian Thanksgiving Recipes (2024)

FAQs

What do vegetarians eat on Thanksgiving instead of turkey? ›

If you really want to serve something that is a nearly seamless substitute for Thanksgiving turkey, there's always Field Roast, a plant-based meat and cheese company that sells soy-free holiday roasts. They are wheat-based vegan stuffed roasts with a sage, rosemary, and bread filling.

What is the most popular vegetarian alternative to roast turkey? ›

Vegan turkey recipes
  1. Vegan Stuffed Seitan Roast. This stuffed seitan is the perfect replacement for a stuffed turkey joint this Christmas. ...
  2. Vegan Turkey Wellington With Walnut Gravy. ...
  3. Vegan Herb-Crumbed Whole Roasted Cauliflower. ...
  4. Leftover Vegetable Christmas Pie. ...
  5. Festive Vegan 'Turkey' Sandwich. ...
  6. Vegan Seitan Twizzlers.

What meat is a popular alternative to turkey on Thanksgiving? ›

Sometimes, roasting a whole turkey is just too much—too much time, effort, and maybe even too much food. For smaller crowds, swap the turkey with chicken, Cornish game hens, or stuff and roast individual quails for each guest, which is very elegant for a plated meal.

How to be vegetarian on Thanksgiving? ›

Vegetarian Thanksgiving Main Dishes
  1. Vegetarian Mushroom Wellington. Alexa Weibel. ...
  2. Spicy Roasted Mushrooms With Polenta. ...
  3. Ombré Gratin. ...
  4. Baked Brie and Caramelized Vegetable Pie. ...
  5. One-Pot Vegetable Biryani. ...
  6. Broccoli Cheese Casserole. ...
  7. Butternut Squash and Fondue Pie With Pickled Red Chiles. ...
  8. Roasted Mushrooms in Ata Din Din.

What are the 3 main vegetarian alternatives to meat? ›

The 10 best vegan meat alternatives
  • Tofu. Tofu is the classic meat alternative and has been one of the basic sources of nutrition in Asia for centuries. ...
  • Soy protein. Soy chunks and mince are very inexpensive ingredients that are easy to prepare. ...
  • Tempeh. ...
  • Seitan/wheat protein. ...
  • Lupin protein. ...
  • Green spelt. ...
  • Oat flakes. ...
  • Black beans.
Nov 11, 2019

What is the most popular vegetarian alternative to a turkey dinner at Christmas? ›

Nut Roast. The most popular Christmas meal for vegetarians and vegans is the nut roast. This typically describes a mixture of nuts, breadcrumbs, leeks, onions, broth and either oil or butter. However, this recipe is malleable and offers the opportunity for many alterations according to personal preference.

What do vegetarians eat instead of ham? ›

Because of its meaty texture and appearance, seitan is a common ingredient in vegan ham. This recipe combines it with tofu to get a really juicy, chewy result that even looks almost identical to the real deal. You could proudly serve this vegan ham for a holiday feast, slice it up for sandwiches, or both!

What is a healthier alternative to turkey? ›

Roasted Whole Chicken

“Each of these can be seasoned to your taste and roasted in the oven, resulting in wonderful aroma and delicious meat,” says Palumbo. Both chicken and turkey are lean proteins, especially if you avoid dark meat.

What do vegetarians eat instead of chicken? ›

Vegan Chicken: Delicious vegetarian and vegan-friendly chicken substitutes
  • Tofu. Tofu is one of the most well-known and versatile vegan and vegetarian-friendly foods out there. ...
  • Soy curls. ...
  • Jackfruit. ...
  • Potato. ...
  • Seitan. ...
  • Tempeh. ...
  • Cauliflower.
May 18, 2023

What is a good protein for Thanksgiving that isn't turkey? ›

Cornish game hen, goose, duck, ham, beef, salmon, and mushroom recipes make worthy centerpieces for holiday meals. This is collaborative content from Food & Wine's team of experts, including staff, recipe developers, chefs, and contributors.

What to make for Thanksgiving if you don't like turkey? ›

Whatever the reason, here are 20 Thanksgiving recipes for a turkey-free table.
  • Roast Chicken With Maple Butter and Rosemary. Image. ...
  • Beef Wellington. Image. ...
  • Ombré Gratin. Image. ...
  • Skillet Pork Chops and Apples With Miso Caramel. Image. ...
  • Samosa Pie. Image. ...
  • Maple-Baked Salmon. Image. ...
  • Lasagna. Image. ...
  • Ina Garten's Make-Ahead Coquilles St.
Nov 10, 2022

What do you say instead of "Happy Thanksgiving"? ›

"May all the good things of life be yours, not only on this day but throughout the coming year." "Wishing you a harvest of blessings, good health and good times." "May you enjoy a bountiful Thanksgiving, a joyous holiday season and healthful, Happy New Year."

What is a silent vegetarian? ›

Most couples opt to prepare for two animal proteins and a "silent," or unadvertised, vegetarian option available upon request.

How to make vegetarian meals more filling? ›

To feel more full while following a vegetarian diet, try incorporating more fiber and whole grains into your meals. Incorporating nuts, seeds, and beans into your diet can help you to feel more satisfied.

What is a vegan substitute for turkey slices? ›

Vegan Turkey Deli Slices
  • 1 16oz block Super Firm Tofu*
  • 180 g 1 1/2 cups vital wheat gluten.
  • 2 Tbsp tapioca starch.
  • 2 Tbsp mushroom seasoning.
  • 1/4 cup nutritional yeast.
  • Black pepper to taste I used a lot!
  • 2 tsp MSG or use more nutritional yeast.
  • 1/2 tsp baking powder.

Are there vegetarian options in turkey? ›

Turkish cooking is actually very heavily vegetarian. There are a plethora of dishes that showcase the delicious, fresh, seasonal produce so widely available in Türkiye.

Can you buy vegetarian turkey? ›

Suitable for Vegetarians. Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat. There have been rare cases of allergic reactions to Quorn® products, which contain mycoprotein.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jeremiah Abshire

Last Updated:

Views: 6166

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (54 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jeremiah Abshire

Birthday: 1993-09-14

Address: Apt. 425 92748 Jannie Centers, Port Nikitaville, VT 82110

Phone: +8096210939894

Job: Lead Healthcare Manager

Hobby: Watching movies, Watching movies, Knapping, LARPing, Coffee roasting, Lacemaking, Gaming

Introduction: My name is Jeremiah Abshire, I am a outstanding, kind, clever, hilarious, curious, hilarious, outstanding person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.